"There's just not that much supply, and there are buyers who have lost out in bidding wars," Port Washington agent Andrew Wu told Newsday in October, describing buyers who are still motivated to purchase. In the same article he said attractive, appropriately priced homes in his area were still selling within a week or two of hitting the market. That observation decides the winter question for most Nassau sellers. The usual advice says spring is when homes sell for more. Month-by-month sales in Nassau over the past year show a smaller gap than that advice implies. What changes most between seasons is how many other sellers you are up against.
Winter and spring in Nassau, side by side
These figures come from OneKey MLS monthly reports for Nassau County single-family homes. The table shows four winter months, two spring months and September 2026, all between November 2025 and September 2026.
| Month | New listings | Inventory | Days on market | Median sale price | % of original list price received | Closed sales |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nov 2025 | 600 | 1,784 | 45 | $840,000 | 98.2% | 621 |
| Dec 2025 | 446 | 1,501 | 46 | $835,000 | 99.0% | 693 |
| Jan 2026 | 672 | 1,497 | 55 | $835,000 | 97.2% | 619 |
| Feb 2026 | 576 | 1,473 | 54 | $850,000 | 98.7% | 489 |
| Apr 2026 | 1,352 | 2,133 | 51 | $852,000 | 99.2% | 478 |
| May 2026 | 1,164 | 2,199 | 51 | $890,000 | 100.3% | 579 |
| Sep 2026 | 929 | 2,318 | 40 | $860,000 | 99.8% | 757 |
You can read the reports yourself on the OneKey MLS market statistics page. Every claim below comes from the rows in that table.
The median price moves with the calendar, and that tells you less than it seems
A seller who lines up December's $835,000 median against May's $890,000 sees a $55,000 reason to wait. But the median in this market rises and falls with the calendar every year. Nassau's single-family median hit a record $910,000 in August 2026, then fell to $860,000 in September. Newsday reported that the Nassau median has fallen from August to September in each of the past three years, and that analysts watch year-over-year changes more closely for that reason.
The median also depends on which homes happen to sell in a given month. In its November report on the fastest-rising Long Island communities, Newsday noted that agents credited part of the jump in places like Manhasset to "a shift in the mix of homes that sold toward the luxury end of the market." May's $890,000 median partly reflects which houses closed that month. It does not show that your house would have sold for $55,000 more if you had waited.
The column that tracks your own result more closely is the percentage of original list price received. It compares each home's sale price with its own first asking price, so a change in the mix of homes sold moves it far less than it moves the median.
The seasonal price gap is one to three points of list
Over the four winter months in the table, Nassau single-family sellers received between 97.2% and 99.0% of their original list price. In April and May 2026 they received 99.2% and 100.3%.
Applied to a home listed at $860,000, roughly September 2026's county median, the gaps look like this:
- January's 97.2% against May's 100.3% is about 3.1 points, or roughly $26,700.
- January against April's 99.2% is 2 points, or about $17,200.
- December's 99.0% against May is 1.3 points, or about $11,200.
The spread between winter months is almost as wide as the spread between winter and spring. December 2025 came within two-tenths of a point of April 2026, and December had more single-family closings, 693, than April or May did. That December total is a lot of deals for a month that conventional wisdom writes off.
These percentages carry a caveat. OneKey notes that its sale-price figures do not account for sale concessions, so a credit negotiated at the closing table does not show up in them.
The competition gap is much wider
Now compare the number of homes. In December 2025, 446 new single-family listings came on the market in Nassau. In April 2026 there were 1,352, about three times as many. Total inventory was 1,473 homes in February and 2,199 in May, so a February seller had about a third fewer competing houses than a May seller.
Spring did not make homes sell much faster either. Days on market ran 54 and 55 in February and January, and 51 in both April and May. The extra spring buyers were spread across far more houses, so the typical listing took only about four days less to sell.
The seasonal choice comes down to a trade. Spring has been worth one to three points of list price in Nassau. Winter cuts the field of competing homes by a third or more, with nearly the same time on market. A house with something buyers would otherwise find in five similar listings nearby gains the most from a smaller field, and buyers who keep shopping in December have fewer choices.
Why this winter is not last winter
Mortgage rates are the new factor this year. Newsday reported on November 12 that the average 30-year fixed rate was 7.18% for the week ending November 5, citing Freddie Mac, nearly a full point above the same week a year earlier. In October, Newsday had put the rate at 7.4% as of October 8, up nearly a point since July.
That cuts both ways for a winter seller. Higher rates reduce what buyers can borrow. Amy Girimonti, an associate broker in Huntington, told Newsday in October, "I don't think home prices are going to change a lot. You may see fewer offers coming in." Higher rates also keep owners from listing. Real estate analyst and appraiser Jonathan Miller told Newsday that this year's rate environment could make Long Island's already low inventory worse and push prices higher.
Supply in Nassau was already tight before this winter. In September 2026, inventory stood at 2,318 single-family homes, down 1.7% from a year earlier, and new listings were down 10.4%. For the third quarter of 2026, OneKey put Nassau at 3.3 months of supply, with sellers receiving 100.5% of original list price on a $880,000 median. The rate surge arrived in a market where buyers were already competing for a small number of homes. Fewer buyers will be shopping this winter, and with owners staying put, fewer houses will be competing for them.
Victor Stabile, an agent who spoke with Newsday about the fall market, summed up Long Island's position: "If you're a seller, you're still king here if it's priced correctly." In the same article he noted that open-house traffic had dropped this fall compared with spring.
Pricing decides the winter result
January's 97.2% is the lowest result in the table, and January's 55 days on market is the highest. Wu described the same problem from the other side when he said sellers whose expectations are too high are "not getting what they were hoping for."
A winter list price based on last May's comparable sales starts the home off overpriced. A list price based on fall closings and the current rate environment lets the home compete for the buyers who are out there. If you are weighing this choice, start by running your home's value against recent closings with our home valuation tool, and see what each price would net you with the home sale calculator. Once you have settled on timing, our step-by-step plan to sell a Nassau County home covers the process.
A few direct questions
Do Nassau condos and co-ops follow the same seasonal pattern? Not as clearly. Nassau co-ops received 97.4% of original list price in January 2026 and 96.4% in May 2026, so spring 2026 did not bring co-op sellers a premium. Condos went from 98.4% in January to 99.6% in May, a 1.2-point rise, smaller than the 3.1-point move for single-family homes over the same months. Monthly condo and co-op sales in Nassau run in the dozens, so a few deals can move these percentages.
Is December really a better month than January? Last season it was. December 2025 single-family sellers received 99.0% of original list price, compared with 97.2% in January 2026, and December had 693 closings. One season is a small sample. What it shows is that winter results varied as much from month to month as winter and spring differed from each other.
Will the competition really be lighter this spring? Spring 2026 brought far more listings. New listings went from 672 in January 2026 to 1,014 in March and 1,164 in May. If Miller is right that higher rates keep more owners from selling, spring 2027 could be tighter than spring 2026. Either way, a winter listing will compete against fewer homes than a spring one.
This post is general market information, not financial advice. Mortgage rates and your own numbers will differ, so confirm them with your lender and advisors before you decide. If you are deciding between a December listing and an April one, Marty Vandenburg and the Elevated Experience Team can price your home both ways against recent Nassau closings. Get your free home valuation and we'll start there.